Search
 
 
Edit Shopping CART(106)  |  Sunday, November 22, 2009
 
 
ARTICLES  &  COMMENTARY
Measuring Distributive Injustice on a Different Scale
 
Greater transparency in health-care financing and more skepticism regarding the purported rationales for hidden cross-subsidies and regulatory protections are sorely overdue.
 

Resident Fellow Thomas P. Miller  
Resident Fellow Thomas P. Miller
 
Download file The full text of this article is available here as an Adobe Acrobat PDF.

I. Introduction

A comprehensive examination of distributive injustice within the U.S. health care system should move well beyond quantitative measures of differences in the flow of finances to acquire health care services. It requires a more concentrated emphasis on differences in health outcomes for lower- versus higher-income Americans and the key non-financial factors that produce them. Specifically, this article highlights the importance of education as a powerful contributor to significant differences in health outcomes. Expanding our vision to capture factors--such as education--outside the narrow scope of conventional health care financing and delivery provides an opportunity to discover better targeted policy interventions to narrow the existing income inequality in overall health outcomes.

Part II of this article explains the evidence that education may be a powerful driver of disparities in health outcomes. Part III illustrates how a more limited distributional analysis of health-services spending in recent studies of the Medicare program has produced sharply conflicting conclusions on whether Medicare financing is regressive or progressive. Part IV then offers a possible [*pg 232] reconciliation of these studies by focusing on the differences in health outcomes that various types of Medicare beneficiaries experience, rather than on the levels of health care spending that they receive. And finally, Part V builds on the preceding findings to suggest how policy interventions may be retargeted to be more effective in narrowing income-related gaps in health.

Thomas P. Miller is a resident fellow at AEI.

Download file The full text of this article is available here as an Adobe Acrobat PDF.