Search
 
 
Edit Shopping CART(16)  |  Sunday, November 22, 2009
 
 
ARTICLES  &  COMMENTARY
The Dismal Questions
 
What questions should John McCain and Barack Obama answer at the second presidential debate?
 

John McCain and Barack Obama will meet tonight in Nashville for the second presidential debate. As Americans worry about a confusing federal rescue plan, a falling stock market, and a financial crisis that is spreading across the globe, the New York Times asked economists to suggest the questions they would most like to hear the candidates answer. R. Glenn Hubbard offered these questions:

 
Visiting Scholar
 R. Glenn Hubbard
 
1. Does the financial crisis indicate that we need more regulation? Or is the problem less one of too little regulation than of poorly focused regulation? The crisis had its origins in part in international capital flows that led to extraordinarily low interest rates. But high-risk mortgage lending drew some of its breath from regulatory interventions. Some heavily regulated financial institutions managed to get themselves in trouble. And it was government-sponsored enterprises, no strangers to regulation, that stimulated the demand for questionable mortgage products. Shouldn't the next president be standing up to protect markets instead of sowing doubts about them?

2. The Federal Reserve has had to step into the political fray to an uncomfortable degree. Are we asking too much of the Fed? Should we create a strong financial regulator that would stand shoulder to shoulder with the Fed?

3. The existing capital standards for financial companies helped create the illusion that risky assets were "safe." A reformed system could mandate more capital, to support incremental risk-taking, during a boom and lower such capital requirements in a bust. By changing capital cushions over credit cycles, banks would be less likely to be forced into asset fire sales. Would you support such a change?

4. Do you support the appointment of a presidential commission to report quickly on the causes of the current crisis and present options for regulatory reform?

R. Glenn Hubbard is a visiting scholar at AEI.