Marty Samuels is right: Clinicians should focus on patient, not society

The lead story in today’s New York Times brings to the fore an emerging question in medicine: when providing care and offering advice, should a physician think only of the patient in front of her, or does she have an obligation to balance the needs of the individual patient with the broader needs of society?

I strongly agree with Harvard neurologist Marty Samuels, who told the NYT, “There should be forces in society who should be concerned about the budget, about how many M.R.I.s we do, but they shouldn’t be functioning simultaneously as doctors."

Added the Times, “Samuels  said doctors risked losing the trust of patients if they told patients, ‘I’m not going to do what I think is best for you because I think it’s bad for the health care budget in Massachusetts.’”

It seems absolutely essential to me that when a patient receives advice from a physician, the patient knows that this reflects the best medical advice from the doctor, and not some murky weighing of whether the patient is more deserving than society.

This prioritization of the individual patient  is consistent with a desire for cost transparency (cost can matter a lot to patients), and with physicians understanding and being able to explain the costs and potential benefits of a range of treatment options (to the extent multiple options are available — sadly, this often is not the case).  (Addendum: as Ashish Jha more eloquently phrased this point, “Should MDs consider costs as it affects their patients? Yes!  How about how $ affect society? Not clear.” [In the case of the treating physician, I'm arguing "no."])

The foundation of the physician-patient relationship, the bedrock of care, is, should, and must be the unshakable trust the patient has that his doctor will do what’s best for him.  Once this faith is breached, it may never be restored, to the permanent detriment of both patients and the profession of medicine.

At that point, physicians will truly transform into the bureaucrats and bean counters they’ve struggled so valiantly not to become.

- – - -

I’ve discussed a number of key issues related to patients and populations extensively before, in three related contexts: (1) Should clinicians focus on patients or populations? (2) End of life (or not) decisions; (3) Balancing patient and population benefit in medical research.  See related links below:

Should Doctors Focus On Patients Or Populations:

Focus Factor: Should Your Doctor Be Thinking About Society’s Healthcare Costs?”

Case Study: What Would You Do Here If You Were The Payor? The Doctor? The Patient?”

Do No Harm – To Patients Or To Populations?”

On End Of Life (or not) Decisions:

Right to Live

End-Of-Life Medical Advice: Devaluing Patients In The Name Of A Greater Good

’But Doctor, I Want To Live!’  The Other Side Of The ‘Dignified Death’ Debate

Balancing Patient and Population Benefit In Medical Research:

A Future We Make For Ourselves: Should We Expand Imperfect Treatments, Or Create New Ones?”

Preserving American (Medical) Exceptionalism

Medicine by Metrics

Also Visit
AEIdeas Blog The American Magazine
About the Author

 

David
Shaywitz

What's new on AEI

Holder will regret his refusal to obey the Constitution
image 'Flood Wall Street' climate protesters take aim at their corporate allies
image 3 opportunities for better US-India defense ties
image Is Nicolás Maduro Latin America's new man at the United Nations?
AEI on Facebook
Events Calendar
  • 29
    MON
  • 30
    TUE
  • 01
    WED
  • 02
    THU
  • 03
    FRI
Thursday, October 02, 2014 | 9:00 a.m. – 10:30 a.m.
Campbell Brown talks teacher tenure

We welcome you to join us as Brown shares her perspective on the role of the courts in seeking educational justice and advocating for continued reform.

Friday, October 03, 2014 | 12:00 p.m. – 1:00 p.m.
Harnessing the power of markets to tackle global poverty: A conversation with Jacqueline Novogratz

AEI welcomes you to this Philanthropic Freedom Project event, in which Novogratz will describe her work investing in early-stage enterprises, what she has learned at the helm of Acumen, and the role entrepreneurship can play in the fight against global poverty.

No events scheduled this day.
No events scheduled this day.
No events scheduled today.
No events scheduled this day.
No events scheduled this day.
No events scheduled this day.