The Pope's Critics

When Karol Wojtyla became Pope in 1978, he was a young and fit 58, ruddy-faced, shaped by the outdoors, vibrant with energy. He took the names of the two Popes of Vatican II, John XXIII and Paul VI, to signify his intention of putting Vatican II into practice as thoroughly round the world as he had already done in Krakow.

One thing was unusual: This new Pope saw the whole Church spread around the planet as one People of God, and his own task as Pope as that of becoming a "universal Pastor." Wherever he went, he surrounded himself with bishops from all over, to show that the papacy is a brotherly teaching office, not a kingly one. Catholic "progressives" in North America, however, will never forgive him. I have met two priests who say with some intensity that they pray every day for his speedy passage to God. Former priest James Carroll calls for the Pope's resignation, and preposterously describes the Pope's policies as "anti-reform--closed, secretive, dishonest, totalitarian."

"Progressives" such as Carroll have developed their own legend about Vatican II. They imagine that Vatican II repealed the strong papacy of Vatican I and even the Council of Trent, and gave the Church over in a revolutionary way to "the people of God." Power to the people!

Last weekend in Boston, for instance, a new organization called Voice of the Faithful compared its own uprising to the U.S. War of Independence in 1776. They predicted a new democratic church, run from the bottom up. Some 66 theologians calling themselves Catholic sent them a letter of theological support.

This new group is trying to decide whether the new church it is founding will be Anglican (that is, Catholic, but without a Pope, sailing with the winds of the times) or Congregationalist (that is, parish-centred and parish-led, with as little to do with bishops and Pope as can be worked out). The one thing clear is that this new group does not want to be Catholic, as Catholic has been understood by, say, the Councils of Trent, Vatican I, and Vatican II. And as Paul VI, and John XXIII and on back, understood it.

The "progressives" will not forgive John Paul II because what they call sexual liberation the Pope, in a quite well-founded, traditional way, regards as the tyranny of the libido, a form of slavery. Whereas they want eagerly to accept the norms of secular society on divorce, homosexual acts, premarital sex, and other pelvic desires, the Pope stands with "the democracy of the dead," the voice of the faithful of the past, so many martyrs, so many lovers of chastity. The Pope's unflinching stand is an outrage to those who regard "Vatican II" as their own playpen, within which to do what they feel like doing. In their minds, "Vatican II" overturned everything unpleasant and challenging in the teaching of the Church. It left them feeling liberated. At this late date, they don't want to re-examine their own legend.

Among the most powerful and deeply resented of the Pope's initiatives is the new, phenomenological foundation he has given "the theology of the body." "Progressives" avoid arguments at that depth. But it is exactly the unity which the Pope sees between soul and body, the unity arising from our persons being thoroughly embodied, and our bodies being thoroughly pervaded by our personhood, that makes the Pope's vision seem so "together." He looks at young people whole. He calls them to their wholeness.

That is what young people are responding to.

Richard McBrien, the theologian at the University of Notre Dame who has not had three kind words for Karol Wojtyla in 24 years, says that the Pope is now too weak, too ill, to be the kind of "draw" that he used to be.

There was never a day on which Richard McBrien could "draw" one hundred thousand young people (much less, think of that as a "low turnout.") I have never had such a day myself.

For Pope John Paul II, anything less than a crowd of four or five million, such as he has had several times since 1978, seems like an intimate gathering.

No man in history has been physically seen by so many people in the flesh at any one time. Altogether, cumulatively, certainly no one comes even close. Those who see him in Toronto will be joining the largest cumulative crowd ever to see one man in history. It is as if he has wanted to bless physically every man and woman on the planet. Even his critics. Even his enemies.

Michael Novak is the George Frederick Jewett Scholar in Religion, Philosophy, and Public Policy at AEI.

Also Visit
AEIdeas Blog The American Magazine
About the Author



What's new on AEI

AEI Election Watch 2014: What will happen and why it matters
image A nation divided by marriage
image Teaching reform
image Socialist party pushing $20 minimum wage defends $13-an-hour job listing
AEI on Facebook
Events Calendar
  • 27
  • 28
  • 29
  • 30
  • 31
Monday, October 27, 2014 | 10:00 a.m. – 11:30 a.m.
State income taxes and the Supreme Court: Maryland Comptroller v. Wynne

Please join AEI for a panel discussion exploring these and other questions about this crucial case.

Tuesday, October 28, 2014 | 9:30 a.m. – 12:15 p.m.
For richer, for poorer: How family structures economic success in America

Join Lerman, Wilcox, and a group of distinguished scholars and commentators for the release of Lerman and Wilcox’s report, which examines the relationships among and policy implications of marriage, family structure, and economic success in America.

Tuesday, October 28, 2014 | 5:30 p.m. – 7:00 p.m.
The 7 deadly virtues: 18 conservative writers on why the virtuous life is funny as hell

Please join AEI for a book forum moderated by Last and featuring five of these leading conservative voices. By the time the forum is over, attendees may be on their way to discovering an entirely different — and better — moral universe.

Thursday, October 30, 2014 | 2:00 p.m. – 3:00 p.m.
A nuclear deal with Iran? Weighing the possibilities

Join us, as experts discuss their predictions for whether the United States will strike a nuclear deal with Iran ahead of the November 24 deadline, and the repercussions of the possible outcomes.

Thursday, October 30, 2014 | 5:00 p.m. – 6:15 p.m.
The forgotten depression — 1921: The crash that cured itself

Please join Author James Grant and AEI senior economists for a discussion about Grant's book, "The Forgotten Depression: 1921: The Crash That Cured Itself" (Simon & Schuster, 2014).

No events scheduled this day.
No events scheduled this day.
No events scheduled this day.
No events scheduled today.
No events scheduled this day.