The public policy blog of the American Enterprise Institute

Subscribe to the blog

Discussion: (14 comments)

  1. re: ‘Why fracking is environmentally sound‘…


    Environmental impact, What nonsense!

  2. If we experience another drought next summer – look out – the battle between Farmers and Oil over sparse water reserves will be contentious.

    1. Che is dead

      Chimera Energy develops fracking technique that uses no water

      The only commodity that counts is the one in unlimited supply – human ingenuity.

      1. I’ll take water.

        Human ingenuity, as great as it is, also faces up against human stupidity – something else in umlimited supply.

        1. Che is dead


      2. MacDaddyWatch

        Fracking has been going on for over 60 years–so far so good !!!

  3. Che is dead

    “Thalidomide was considered virtually 100% safe at one time too.” — bart

    Thanks, for that moronic little non sequitur.

  4. Hell_Is_Like_Newark

    The rest of the world is pretty much failing to tap their resources. A primary reason is that the people who’s land would be drilled receive no monetary benefit (royalties). The USA is unique in giving individuals mineral rights. The rest of the world, the minerals belong to the government.

    Therefore there is no incentive for a private property owner to allow drilling.

  5. This type of questioning on a program called Hardtalk? That explains the name ‘Spice Girls’ for this lot.

    You would think that someone would ask about why so many of the producers can’t self finance.

  6. Two points

    1 – The statement by Mr. Voser that the compounds used for fracking are biodegradable assumes that the biological organisms present at the depth where the fracking takes place can biodegrade those materials. Maybe the compost pile in my back yard can render the chemicals harmless, but will the activity taking place thousands of feet below the surface do the same?

    2 – On the whole issue of energy independence, why do you want it? Aside from the fact that its a global market and the price of oil drilled in the well 2 miles from my house cost the same at the pump as the oil drilled half way around the world are the same, as Milton Freedman points out in the video in the post immediately below this one: “The proper objective for a nation as Adam Smith put it is to arrange things so we get as large a volume of imports as possible for as small a volume of exports as possible.” Or as someone in a recent movie put it “I drink YOUR milkshake”. In short – suck the Arabian desert’s oil as hard, as fast and for as long as they are willing to sell it to us because once they run dry they are once again as powerless as the sand in the desert they are pumping from. Then the oil below my feet will still be here, more valuable than ever. Safely preserved by mother nature for when we need it most.

    1. MacDaddyWatch

      1-The fracking takes place thousands of feet below any water shed and its separated by that many feet of impermeable rock–so impermeable that the rock has successfully prevented leakage for many millions of years.

      2-Our current sources of middle eastern crude are the sworn enemy of america and freedom.

      3-So far, your “mistake” is like global warming–all bullshlt.

      1. Yes, but you’re either unaware of or intentionally avoiding all the explosives (as in mini earthquakes) used below all those so-called impermeable rocks during fracking.

        I suggest that you take a very close look at the data. If you increase the sensitivity enough you will find lots of seismic activity everywhere. It is a lot like the people who claim that the hurricane count has gone up the last three decades but forget to mention that has to do with the ability to use satellites to see storm activity that was never observed during previous periods.

  7. MacDaddyWatch

    Europe has huge supplies of shale oil and gas but fracking in the EU is not going to be big there because, unlike the USA, the various EU governments own the underground resource. The’ll need a decade or more to deal with this state ownership problem that is currently blocking fracking in the EU.

  8. One major item missing from the rosy view of shale benefits in the US is the complete lack of any recognition that other countries have shale oil and gas.

    The problem with tight oil and gas in shale formations is the low energy return on the energy invested. Shale is not a solution because outside of a few small core areas the projects are not self financing. This is shown in the 10-K filings and is mentioned in the conference calls but the information is ignored by the promoters and charlatans who portray themselves as ‘independent’ analysts.

Comments are closed.

Sort By:

Refine Content:


Additional Keywords:

Refine Results

or to save searches.

Refine Content