Discussion: (6 comments)
Comments are closed.
The public policy blog of the American Enterprise Institute
View related content: Pethokoukis
A popular explanation, at least on the right, for the slow US economic recovery blames policy “uncertainty.” Business investment is weak because CEOs are worried about, for instance, the many facets of Obamanomics — particularly Obamacare’s taxes, spending, and regulations — but also the huge rise in the national debt. Maybe a debt crisis is coming soon (although little sign of that can be seen in the dollar or US treasury rates).
Economic uncertainty during the Great Recession and its immediate aftermath chilled business and consumers. Fear of total economic collapse was running high. And business didn’t much like the 2011 debt ceiling battle. Here are the authors of the Economic Policy Uncertainty Index, Scott Baker and Nicholas Bloom, in 2012:
Our index shows sharp spikes in economic policy uncertainty around major elections, wars and the 9/11 terrorist attacks. More recently, it spiked sharply after the Lehman bankruptcy in September 2008 and the passage of the Troubled Asset Relief Program (TARP) legislation shortly afterwards. It remained high until late 2011, driven by continuing policy uncertainty around the 2010 mid-term elections, the debt ceiling dispute and the crisis of the Eurozone. Only over the last couple of months has policy uncertainty finally started to drop back down to more normal levels.
Indeed, uncertainty — at least of the sort tracked by Baker and Bloom — has continued to decline. Yet, as a JPMorgan note recently pointed out, business spending has moderated, too. JPM: “In short, spending trends through this expansion seem at odds with the uncertainty-driven story of capital spending.”
A new CEO survey also suggests that dramatic drop in uncertainty leading won’t spur dramatically more investment. From the WSJ: “U.S. business leaders, encouraged by the recent break in Washington’s budget gridlock, are increasingly looking to boost spending. But that probably won’t come in ways that would drive rapid hiring or economic growth, according to a new Business Roundtable survey of top CEOs.”
On the other hand, business would invest more if executives thought economic growth would accelerate, pointing to tax reform as a way of making that happen.
But what about small business? This analysis is from the February NFIB Small Business Economic Trends report:
Uncertainty is a major cause of the reluctance to spend and hire. Large firms are loaded with cash but unwilling to spend. For small firms, record low numbers are reporting the current period as a good time to expand, for 5 years and running. More firms are reducing inventory than adding to it, even in a growing economy. And more firms are expecting a deterioration in the economy than an improvement. In NFIB’s Problems and Priorities
survey, uncertainty about the economy and government policy both rank in the top 5 most severe problems facing small business owners. You don’t bet your money on a future you cannot see clearly.
According to the NFIB, small biz optimism remains at historically low levels. But why? When you look at the survey results, a number of issues pop up:
Now when I look at the NFIB historical charts (below), the two problems that strike as being unusually acute on a historical bases are sales and regulation. One demand-side issue, one supply-side issue:
Taken all together, the above info suggests continued need for continued monetary action, as well as regulatory and tax reform. So a little something for everybody.
Comments are closed.
1150 17th Street, N.W. Washington, D.C. 20036
© 2015 American Enterprise Institute for Public Policy Research